Marjory McKeraker or McGregor. Admitted 1861. Murder

Home
Learning and events
Exhibition: Prisoners or Patients? Criminal Insanity in Victorian Scotland
Marjory McKeraker or McGregor. Admitted 1861. Murder

Share this page

Click here to share this page on Facebook. Click here to share this page on LinkedIn. Click here to share this page on X (formerly known as Twitter).

Marjory McKeraker or McGregor murdered George Munro, her illegitimate son, aged four. Child murders made up half the female admissions to Perth’s Criminal Lunatic Department (CLD), these mostly of older, rather than new-born infants.

Photograph of Marjory taken from the Criminal Lunatic Department Case Book. Crown copyright, NRS, HH21/48/1 p98.

Post mortem report into the death of George Munro by William Menzies M.C. and J.B. Reid, Surgeon, 2 February 1861, p1-2. Crown copyright, NRS, AD14/61/7.

Medical Report
Aberfeldy February 2nd 1861

We hereby certify on soul and conscience that on the 30th January last we visited and jointly examined the body of George Munro at Upper Acharn.

Deceased appeared to be between four and five years of age, the body was still warm and death must have been quite recent. On examination we found a severe incised wound or cut, extending from within an inch of the middle of the back of the right ear to a point about half an inch below and in front of the lower lobe of the left ear. the wound reached to the bone throughout most of its extent dividing all the muscles and bloodvessels in its course.

No other marks of external violence were visible and the child appeared to be healthy and well developed.

We are of the opinion that death was caused by hemorhage from said wound.

Signed William Menzies M.D
J.B. Reid Surgeon

There were two strands to how contemporaries understood Marjory’s horrific act. The first was ‘derangement of religious thoughts’, Marjory being an avid attender of the radical Free Church of Scotland that flourished in her native Highland Perthshire. Victorians believed misdirected religious devotion could manifest and cause derangement, especially among women, whose minds they thought weaker than men’s.

“Afraid of the devil…her mind tossed between hope and despair, sleepless, attempted to throw herself out of the window, thought herself lost, dying, burning secretly and suddenly got hold of a razor and cut her child’s throat and then attempted her own. The opinion of the witnesses was that revival excitement had brought on this paroxysm of insanity. A few Sundays before she spoke out in prayer in church and the clergyman thought her mind was wrong (afflicted), very ignorant of the Scriptures, mind considered by several witnesses not strong; got drunk at times. When calm she looked sane, but now and then became suddenly mad on her way to Perth and outrageous.”

Both legal and medical authorities looked closely at personal morality because they thought insanity was the result of failures in character.

“She is reported to have been a very loose character, at one time on the poor roll. She has had two illegitimate children and has lived with other men, previous to her marriage with her present husband, who is said to be a weak fellow.”

Petite at 4 feet 10 inches tall (1.5m), with a fresh complexion, black hair, and grey eyes, when first imprisoned, Marjory spoke of ‘the wickedness of her past life’. She said, the devil came to her and told her that reading the Bible would stop her getting to ‘the good place’. Asked about the murder, she said she ‘believed that she and her boy were “in the bad place” and that to get out of it, her duty was to cut her own and the child’s throat’. But a few days later she spoke of ‘the love she bore him and with sorrow and remorse at the deed she had done, recalling with convulsive weeping the parting smile of her child as she was to seize the murderous weapon’.

Marjory’s homicidal attack was a one-off and she made good progress in her early years at Perth, first conditionally released in 1875. The problem was prisoners under conditional release required a guardian. Private individuals responsible for their supervision, Guardians were legally answerable to the Scottish Office. The records note that ‘her friends [relatives, including two married sisters living in Perthshire] are not at all likely to come forward’ and the compassionate householders who did take her in sooner or later thought better of the arrangement.

Letter from Marjory to the Secretary of State from the Home Department, 3 April 1863, p1-2. NRS, HH18/51.

General Prison for Scotland
Perth April 3rd 1863

To Her Majesty’s Secretary of State for The Home Department The Petition of Convict 181/20 Marjory McKerchar or McGregor at present a Prisoner in the Lunatic Department of the General Prison for Scotland at Perth.

Humbly Sheweth

That I Marjory McKerchar or McGregor your Petitioner was tried on the sixth day of April one thousand Eight Hundred and sixty one years at the Circuit Court of Perth was found Guilty of the Murder of my Child and sentenced to be kept in confinement during Her Majesty’s pleasure at the time I committed the melancholy deed. I was in an unsound state of mind and continued so untill a few weeks after my trial and subsequent admission to this place I am now through the mercy of God perfectly well both in mind and body my husband is willing to take me home therefore I humbly beg that your Lordship will so interest your self in my behalf as to recommend to Her Most Gracious Majesty Queen Victoria that I be set at liberty and I as in duty bound shall ever pray

Marjory Kerchar or McGregor.

By the 1880s resident and visiting medical men were unanimous that ‘hers is really a deserving case’ for discharge. Between 1877 and her unconditional discharge in 1907, at the age of 74, Marjory went through several guardians and two readmissions.

We last read of her living with a married niece in Dundee, working as a cleaner.

Was this page helpful? *

Yes

Yes, but

Your comments

Transcription of the post mortem report into the death of George Munro, 2 February 1861. NRS, AD14/61/7

Transcription of a letter from Marjory to the Secretary of State from the Home Department, 3 April 1863. NRS, HH18/51